Tribunal Determines NCAT Rules 2014 s42 Issues in Contradiction to Parties Wishes and Established Departmental Protocols, 08.07.2026
The NSW Civil & Administrative Tribunal (NCAT) has today issued an unexpected decision concerning a Mr Zidar’s request to access public records under the NCAT Rules 2014 Section 42, records which have not been classified as confidential.
Mr Zidar had initially made an application to the NCAT Registrar for various documents utilising the non-party application form (hyperlink) for Tribunal records including Submissions.
The decision is in response to a Miscellaneous Application from Mr Zidar presently involved in proceedings with the Office of the NSW Information & Privacy Commission (IPC), where there is contention about the proper construction of the interaction between the Government Information (Information Commissioner) Act 2009, GIIC Act, and the Government Information (Public Access) Act 2009, GIPA Act.
Mr Zidar earlier lodged an Access Application for government information held by the IPC, but not satisfied with the response he sought Administrative Review in the NCAT.
The IPC provided a Notice of Decision making clear he had review rights including Internal Review rights directly with the IPC and additionally with NCAT, and so he embarked on that process. The IPC’s published Fact Sheets attached to those decisions on the issue further confirmed Internal Review and NCAT review rights were legally available.
However, the IPC has since indicated Mr Zidar requires consent from the NSW Supreme Court to commence administrative review proceedings in NCAT under the GIIC Act 2009 Section 42, which makes reference to commencing proceedings against the Commissioner or a member of staff personally, and not the Information Commission as an agency.
“This is not a review of a decision or any action by the Commissioner or any member of staff. It is a review of a decision by her office as the GIPA Act 2009 binds the Crown, and so it is applicable to the IPC as an agency. You can imagine my surprise when I was advised I had to go the NSW Supreme Court for permission before proceeding with a standard NCAT administrative review! The thing is, both Notice of Decisions, being the original decision and Internal Review, stated I could go to NCAT which aligns with every other agency. There was no mention about seeking special consent to do anything,” stated Mr Zidar.
“In the meantime of all this I lodged a request to the NCAT Registry for access to other parties’ files, parties with similar issues to mine, in order to better inform me and assist my case. The Registry refused so I was forced to take another step and lodge a Miscellaneous Application to review the Registry’s decision.”
Once the Miscellaneous Application was lodged, Mr Zidar was advised that the parties to the earlier proceedings would be notified and asked to make formal written submissions in relation to Mr Zidar’s request.
The NCAT’s decision today documents Mr Zidar’s Miscellaneous Application to seek records from those other NCAT Applicants concerning proceedings involving the IPC. One party gave their consent for release of tribunal documents in their own respective case. The IPC, as party to those proceedings, also gave consent.
In stark contrast to those consents today’s decision refuses Mr Zidar access to the those records.Mr Zidar was also advised by one of the parties he’d taken incorrect proceedings by the use of the Miscellaneous Application, which followed an Application to Access Records by a Non-Party under the NCAT Rules 2014 Section 42.
The Miscellaneous Application form clearly states a person who is aggrieved by a decision of the NCAT Registrar can use the form to seek a review by a Tribunal Member.
However, the member told Mr Zidar the form was wrong and inapplicable.
Today’s decision states the Tribunal has no jurisdiction to review Registry decisions, which is contradiction to information emanating from Principal Registrar Bechini herself.
So where does that leave any person who disagrees with a Registry decision?
Well and truly up NCAT Creek according to this Tribunal Member. “It’s just another example of the ad-hoc processes in NCAT which all work against the public. And where is the NCAT President Her Honour Lea Armstrong? Where does she stand on this departmental form? And how is it her subordinates are dictating how and when the nominated forms can be used? I think she’s a Clayton’s President; the one you have when you’re not really having one,” stated Mr Zidar.
“I have seen this process numerous times. Non-parties sometimes seek access the result of published information on the website www.caselaw.nsw.gov.au. This means the names, the personal information, are generally published. However, the Registrar has been refusing access to the potential release of personal information. The issue with this is that personal information is not categorised as personal information once it’s been released. In this case, published caselaw identifying parties, is not classified as personal information. It’s a ploy. It’s nothing else. It’s just another excuse to avoid transparency. We can see, hear, and covertly record hearings in the High Court of Australia, and the Independent Commission Against Corruption. But NCAT remains top secret. This is the lowest court in NSW; in fact it’s not even a court it’s a tribunal. And it’s not transparent or open in any way,” stated Telina Webb of NSW Freedom of Information. NSW Freedom of Information will continue to follow this case.
The IPC provided a Notice of Decision making clear he had review rights including Internal Review rights directly with the IPC and additionally with NCAT, and so he embarked on that process. The IPC’s published Fact Sheets attached to those decisions on the issue further confirmed Internal Review and NCAT review rights were legally available.
However, the IPC has since indicated Mr Zidar requires consent from the NSW Supreme Court to commence administrative review proceedings in NCAT under the GIIC Act 2009 Section 42, which makes reference to commencing proceedings against the Commissioner or a member of staff personally, and not the Information Commission as an agency.
“This is not a review of a decision or any action by the Commissioner or any member of staff. It is a review of a decision by her office as the GIPA Act 2009 binds the Crown, and so it is applicable to the IPC as an agency. You can imagine my surprise when I was advised I had to go the NSW Supreme Court for permission before proceeding with a standard NCAT administrative review! The thing is, both Notice of Decisions, being the original decision and Internal Review, stated I could go to NCAT which aligns with every other agency. There was no mention about seeking special consent to do anything,” stated Mr Zidar.
“In the meantime of all this I lodged a request to the NCAT Registry for access to other parties’ files, parties with similar issues to mine, in order to better inform me and assist my case. The Registry refused so I was forced to take another step and lodge a Miscellaneous Application to review the Registry’s decision.”
Once the Miscellaneous Application was lodged, Mr Zidar was advised that the parties to the earlier proceedings would be notified and asked to make formal written submissions in relation to Mr Zidar’s request.
The NCAT’s decision today documents Mr Zidar’s Miscellaneous Application to seek records from those other NCAT Applicants concerning proceedings involving the IPC. One party gave their consent for release of tribunal documents in their own respective case. The IPC, as party to those proceedings, also gave consent.
In stark contrast to those consents today’s decision refuses Mr Zidar access to the those records.Mr Zidar was also advised by one of the parties he’d taken incorrect proceedings by the use of the Miscellaneous Application, which followed an Application to Access Records by a Non-Party under the NCAT Rules 2014 Section 42.
The Miscellaneous Application form clearly states a person who is aggrieved by a decision of the NCAT Registrar can use the form to seek a review by a Tribunal Member.
However, the member told Mr Zidar the form was wrong and inapplicable.
Today’s decision states the Tribunal has no jurisdiction to review Registry decisions, which is contradiction to information emanating from Principal Registrar Bechini herself.
So where does that leave any person who disagrees with a Registry decision?
Well and truly up NCAT Creek according to this Tribunal Member. “It’s just another example of the ad-hoc processes in NCAT which all work against the public. And where is the NCAT President Her Honour Lea Armstrong? Where does she stand on this departmental form? And how is it her subordinates are dictating how and when the nominated forms can be used? I think she’s a Clayton’s President; the one you have when you’re not really having one,” stated Mr Zidar.
“I have seen this process numerous times. Non-parties sometimes seek access the result of published information on the website www.caselaw.nsw.gov.au. This means the names, the personal information, are generally published. However, the Registrar has been refusing access to the potential release of personal information. The issue with this is that personal information is not categorised as personal information once it’s been released. In this case, published caselaw identifying parties, is not classified as personal information. It’s a ploy. It’s nothing else. It’s just another excuse to avoid transparency. We can see, hear, and covertly record hearings in the High Court of Australia, and the Independent Commission Against Corruption. But NCAT remains top secret. This is the lowest court in NSW; in fact it’s not even a court it’s a tribunal. And it’s not transparent or open in any way,” stated Telina Webb of NSW Freedom of Information. NSW Freedom of Information will continue to follow this case.
Contact us using this form to comment on this article.